User login
Navigation
Newsletter
Popular content
Recent blog posts
Active forum topics
Recent comments
Who's new
Who's online
There are currently 0 users and 1 guest online.
|
Ask the expertsWhile on my recent safari to Amboseli and Tsavo East I couldn't help but notice a big difference in the elephants. In Amboseli, though the dry season there also, the elephants usually come quite quietly into the park and, whether at the swamps or where-ever you see them, they are quiet and orderly. You also don't often see them chasing another family away from a given area. In Tsavo this time, I noticed that the elephants were much more vocal with far more rumbling and trumpeting than I've seen at Amboseli. I also noticed there is a pronounced hierarchy between families and one family will chase another family away from the waterhole. The only reason I can think of is because there is far more water available in Amboseli thus making the elephants more content and agreeable with one another. In Tsavo there are far fewer waterholes, with as many as 400 elephants at one time at that waterhole, and perhaps this is causing it. Also in Tsavo there were so many females in estrous! Lots of mating going on. Have any of you noticed a big difference between the elephant herds in other parts of Kenya? Is water a factor making elephants more or less vocal? Can the dry season bring on estrous cycles? In 12 trips to Kenya, I've never seen to many estrous females all at once or so much "talking" going on. Would love to hear your opinions/experiences as to why these differences are so noticeable. |
One 'expert' wades in....
Tue, 2007-09-11 08:21 by Keith
Your questions raise a few different issues -- conditions in dry v wet season, timing of oestrus, dominance behaviour -- and I will try to give you some answers, from the area where I have SOME expertise, i.e. feeding ecology and demography. I will let others the opportunity to comment on social behaviour and competition.
So... about dry seaons and elephant condition. We have seen year after year in Amboseli that the elephants become increasingly quiet and conservative as dry seasons progress and food gets scarce, and in drier years this is more pronounced. They are conserving energy, as their body condition declines in response to reduced food quality and quantity. In contrast, when it rains and the grass grows tall and nutritious, the elephants quickly regain their condition and energy, interact and play, come into oestrus and musth, make a lot of noise and just generally carry on. In years whe there is more rain and/or a longer wet season, these high spirits can last longer into the months of Msy, even June, while in years when the rains stop early, as happened this year in Amboseli, the "fun" stops earlier and the elephants put their heads down and try to get through until the rains come. This contrast in conditions can be found between places, as well as between different seasons or years; so if Tsavo had longer rains and better food -- does anyone know about Tsavo this year? -- the elephants there would still be in good shape, with lots of energy and mating, compared to those in Amboseli. When was your visit, Jan; what months and what was the vegetation like? Still green?
As for more competition and chasing at waterholes in Tsavo, I would agree with your suggestion. Yes, there would be more interaction over access to waterholes where they are restricted, compared to the wider access that elephants enjoy in Amboseli. And certain vocalizations could be pronounced, but here I would defer to Joyce.
I hope that these few off-the-cuff comments help you. It's v interesting to hear about differences between populations, as it puts our work in Amboseli in a broader context, and helps us understand better the "rules" of elephant ecology and behaviour.
Keith
Amboseli versus Tsavo elephant actions
Tue, 2007-09-11 10:10 by Jan
Keith:
Thanks so much for your reply. I saw the Amboseli elephants and the Tsavo elephants in February after the rains when everything was lush and green and much food and full waterholes everywhere. There was, as you stated, much more "fun" and playing going on in Amboseli. We often watched large groups "swimming" in a waterhole we named "the beach" on many days. Tsavo was also green in February with waterholes everywhere and the elephants were scattered all over the park.
However on my last trip 7-30 - 8-16 things were much drier in both places - much more so in Tsavo. Though I've been in both places 12 times, always in the dry season, I've never heard as many rumblings and trumpetings as I did this time in Tsavo, as much mating going on or one group chasing another away from the waterholes before. It was an interesting comparison that I had never noticed before and thus my supposition that it probably was due to the shortage of food and water in Tsavo. On one occasion a huge bull of about 50 years old with huge tusks approached the waterhole for a drink and a young bull chased him away! One would just have assumed that because of his age and condition, that no-one would bother with him. He left the area of the waterholes and stood waiting for several hours until some of the younger guys left before he eventually got his water.
Thanks again for your interesting information.